Glenn Youngkin transgender policy sparks controversy
November 21, 2022
Glenn Youngkin announced in mid-September that he is aiming to roll back the rights of transgender students in Virginia schools. The proposed policy would require students to use bathrooms and locker rooms that align with their assigned sex, along with schools requiring parental consent to make alterations to a student’s preferred name and pronouns.
These regulations will likely have a monumental impact on Virginia students who identify as transgender. Not only may they feel as though their identities do not matter to others, they may also be endangered. If a teacher is required to share information on a student’s gender identity with parents, then students may face major repercussions at home based on the ideologies of the parents.
The policies instantly sparked a controversy throughout a multitude of Northern Virginia schools, with a plethora of organized walkouts being staged on September 23rd, 2022. Hayfield, often accoladed as the most diverse public high school in Fairfax County, is expected to be heavily affected by the implemented measures. At 2:20, hundreds of students flooded the halls as they made their way to the football stadium to make their voices heard in protest. Led by a bellowing group in the upper half of the bleachers, Hayfield students joined together to make their thoughts known.
Students wielded signs reading “Respect Trans Rights”, “Trans Rights Are Human Rights”, and “I Should Be In Class, Not Fighting For My Safety”, and bellowed chants and speeches at the top of their lungs.
Students attending Hayfield’s walkout had a resounding group opinion, with many feeling a strong opposition to the ideals of the governor. Senior Meredyth Walker was one of them, believing that the policies are unjust and unnecessary.
“I don’t think it’s a good thing,” Walker said. “I think people should be able to express themselves and how they feel, especially in the community of our school. They’re there most of the time [during their day], so not having that right isn’t fair.”
Walker also commented on how the Hayfield community will be affected, along with what needs to be done in response.
“I think this is going to bring our community together,” Walker said. “I think it’ll bring a positive light to Hayfield and keep us going as a community that can express itself the way it wants. I don’t think we should have to change who we are and students should have their rights given to them.”
Similar thoughts resonated in others.
“I think it’s dumb that we even have to do this,” senior John Holland said of the walkout. “It really should never have come to this. Glenn Youngkin needs to do better.”
Junior Jasper Harris-Edwards felt the same, particularly concerning gender-specific school facilities.
“I think it’s a good topic to walk out on,” Harris-Edwards said. “People should be allowed to use whichever bathroom aligns with the gender they identify with.”
A public comment period was implemented to last until October 26, at which point the policies were planned to roll into schools. The state of Virginia has had these comment periods before on other controversial topics, with 9,086 comments being made under the previous Governor Northam. By October 2, 2022, there were already over 54,000.
On October 17, acting principal Matthew Mough commented on the measures that both Hayfield and Fairfax County Public Schools are taking in response to Youngkin’s policy alterations.
“In addition to Superintendent Reid’s message to the community regarding the topic, FCPS high school principals issued a joint statement voicing support for all of our students and affirming who they are,” Mough said. “Currently, we are awaiting further guidance as the comment period comes to a close and FCPS makes further decisions on how to proceed. We will always stand ready to support our students and who they are.”
In the days following the comment period, an October 28 30-day pushback was declared by the Virginia Department of Education, delaying the measures as they are reviewed regarding comments stating that they contradict previously implemented state laws. The governor stated that he will be working closely with the department to ensure every school district abides by his laws as soon as possible.
Despite these acts of severe pushback from Virginia students, faculty, and counties alike, Governor Youngkin and the Virginia Office of the Attorney General both have plans to continue adamantly pushing his legislation towards public schools across the state, however it is unsure how he will enforce them.
Jacob • Nov 30, 2022 at 8:10 pm
Impressive writing!
Jocelyn • Nov 30, 2022 at 8:03 pm
Well said Andrew!
Meredyth • Nov 30, 2022 at 12:49 pm
So well written Andrew!
Paige • Nov 22, 2022 at 8:02 am
What “rights” of a segment of the school population are being rolled back? Is it the “right” of a girl to feel safe and have privacy from boys in the girls bathroom being rolled back? Is it the “right” of a girl competing on a girls team being rolled back to include boys? Is it the “right” of teachers to NOT be forced into compelled speech without punishment from the school administration being rolled back? What “rights” of trans kids are being eliminated? It appears the “rights” of students and teachers and parents are being restored.
Maya • Nov 30, 2022 at 12:41 pm
This is satire right?
Arthur • Nov 30, 2022 at 1:07 pm
Trans men are men and trans women are women. They deserve basic humans rights, and the governor is trying to take those away. If these were your rights on the line, I think this would be a different story. Trans rights <3
Norah • Dec 1, 2022 at 5:41 pm
It seems your idea of “rights” might be a little confused. You see, no true “right” should ever infringe on someone else’s innate birthright to live freely, unless that free action harms others. In this case, the choice of a trans man, woman, or person, to engage in an activity that aligns with their identity is harming absolutely no one. I can assure you that the trans community never wanted their lives to become the political mess you have made it.
I’m going to make the assumption that when you said “boys” you actually meant “trans women.” You might have made that mistake because you lack exposure to trans woman. If this is the case, I could see how you would be misinformed about the differences between trans women and women. Trans women look the same outwardly, and act the same (whatever that may mean to you), the only difference being that they were assigned the incorrect gender at birth. If you don’t lack exposure, and simply choose to be bigoted, then I would ask that you do some internal reflection on the ways that fear, instead of love, guide your beliefs.
Jaslyn Truong • Nov 21, 2022 at 10:10 am
Great story Andrew